Pooch & Mutt Primal Dry Food vs Lily's Kitchen Puppy Dry Dog Food - Chicken, Salmon & Peas

Same open algorithm, same data, side by side - so the label wins, not the marketing. How we rate

The short answer

Pooch & Mutt Primal Dry Food takes it +1 point

86/100 Pooch & Mutt Primal Dry Food vs 85/100 Lily's Kitchen Puppy Dry Dog Food - Chicken, Salmon & Peas

Both scored by the same open algorithm - the full working is below, every point accounted for.

Attribute	Pooch & Mutt Pooch & Mutt Primal Dry Food Full review	Lily's Kitchen Lily's Kitchen Puppy Dry Dog Food - Chicken, Salmon & Peas Full review
ODF Score	86/100 Very good (best in this row)	85/100 Very good
Price per day	£1.35 / day approx.	£1.35 / day
Best price per kg	£7.00 / kg	£6.79 / kg (best in this row)
Food type	Dry	Dry
Life stage	Puppy & adult & senior	Puppy
Properties	Grain free Gluten free Natural	Grain free Gluten free Natural
Nutrition
Protein (% DM)	31.1%	31.5% est.
Fat (% DM)	18.9%	17.4% est.
Est. carbs (% DM)	37.1%	39.7% est.
Fibre (% DM)	3.1%	3.3% est.
Ash (% DM)	9.8%	8.2% est.
Energy	376 kcal/100g	~365 kcal/100g est.
First 5 ingredients	Venison 32% Lamb 26% Peas 15% Chicken fat 12% Duck meal 10%	Chicken 44% Salmon 10% Chicken liver 7% Sweet potato Pea protein
Where the points went
Ingredient quality (of 40)	32.6 / 40	32.7 / 40 (best in this row)
Meat content (of 15)	15 / 15	15 / 15
Labelling clarity (of 15)	15 / 15 (best in this row)	13 / 15
Additives (of 10)	10 / 10	10 / 10
Nutritional balance (of 10)	7.7 / 10	8.4 / 10 (best in this row)
Processing (of 10)	6 / 10	6 / 10
Red-flag penalties	0	0
Label last verified	July 18, 2026	July 27, 2026

Green-tinted cells mark the best value in that row - highest score, lowest price, most points.

ODF Score: 86/100 Very good best
Price per day: £1.35 / day approx.
Best price per kg: £7.00 / kg
Food type: Dry
Life stage: Puppy & adult & senior
Properties: Grain free Gluten free Natural
Protein (% DM): 31.1%
Fat (% DM): 18.9%
Est. carbs (% DM): 37.1%
Fibre (% DM): 3.1%
Ash (% DM): 9.8%
Energy: 376 kcal/100g
First 5 ingredients: Venison 32% Lamb 26% Peas 15% Chicken fat 12% Duck meal 10%
Ingredient quality (of 40): 32.6 / 40
Meat content (of 15): 15 / 15
Labelling clarity (of 15): 15 / 15 best
Additives (of 10): 10 / 10
Nutritional balance (of 10): 7.7 / 10
Processing (of 10): 6 / 10
Red-flag penalties: 0
Label last verified: July 18, 2026

ODF Score: 85/100 Very good
Price per day: £1.35 / day
Best price per kg: £6.79 / kg best
Food type: Dry
Life stage: Puppy
Properties: Grain free Gluten free Natural
Protein (% DM): 31.5% est.
Fat (% DM): 17.4% est.
Est. carbs (% DM): 39.7% est.
Fibre (% DM): 3.3% est.
Ash (% DM): 8.2% est.
Energy: ~365 kcal/100g est.
First 5 ingredients: Chicken 44% Salmon 10% Chicken liver 7% Sweet potato Pea protein
Ingredient quality (of 40): 32.7 / 40 best
Meat content (of 15): 15 / 15
Labelling clarity (of 15): 13 / 15
Additives (of 10): 10 / 10
Nutritional balance (of 10): 8.4 / 10 best
Processing (of 10): 6 / 10
Red-flag penalties: 0
Label last verified: July 27, 2026

Ingredient differences

What only one recipe contains - the shared ingredients are tucked away at the bottom.

These recipes are 9% the same: 4 shared ingredients, and 40 that appear in only one of them. The differences are below.

Venison Lamb Duck meal Pumpkin Apple pulp Chondroitin MOS (prebiotic) FOS (prebiotic) Yucca Rosemary Turmeric Spirulina

Show the 4 ingredients they share

Peas Chicken fat Carrot Glucosamine

Good quality Acceptable / watch the amount Red flag

This is label analysis, not veterinary advice - if your dog has a health condition, talk to your vet before switching foods.